This email problem started about 4 or 5 years ago when Blogger did some sort of upgrade or change. It is not an unknown issue and I think it has stopped a lot of people from blogging.
Also, there are some commenters that you will never receive email notification from ever. I have about four followers like this. For this reason I check my blog comments so I don't miss them. This shouldn't happen and I don't know why. Sorry.
This explanation below is simplistic and I am making the assumption that the reader is not familiar with Blogger. I hope no one will take offence. I did it this way as I have written many how to guides for various systems and you cannot make the assumption that your audience knows what you know.
Here goes........
At the top left of your blog's front page you will see a link called "Design". Click on this. It will take you to the back end of Blogger.
On the left hand side there is an option called "Settings". Click on this.
You are now in the settings option area. You will see one called "Email".
All is good ....maybe....but maybe not.
Remove the email and click "Save settings".
Now reenter the email you wish to use for comment notification. Save settings again.
Repeat the above step again......remove your email......save settings.....input your email....save settings.
I know it doesn't make sense doing it twice or even three times but it is a necessary step.
You should then get an email from noreply+subscribe@blogger.com asking if you wish to subscribe to comment notification.
So in the perfect world the problem should be fixed :)
There is one other step to take just in case.
On the settings sidebar there is an option "Posts, comments and sharing".
Click on this and take a look to see what you have set up. The question is "Who can Comment?.
What you wish to choose is of course up to you but I personally think the best choice is to select "Anyone". If you restrict it to only users with Google Accounts then there will be some people who will not be able to leave comments ever.
So that's it. Hope this helps.
Take care :)









